For those who know the location of the old church:

From Holy Infant Church (York Haven):  Total 4.1 miles.
From sign in front of church drive North on 382 towards Newberrytown.
In 1.3 miles make a left unto Cly Road. (just past Beer Distributor)
Follow Cly Road for .8 miles at “T” make right onto Bower’s Bridge Road.
Drive on Bower’s Bridge Road for 1.7 mile until stop sign.
Make left onto Conewago Creek Road and drive for .2 miles. (Caution making left)
New church  is on your right.
 
Simpler Directions from Rt. 83:

From the North: Take 83 South to the Strinestown exit (exit 28); Make a left at the end of exit ramp onto Susquehanna Trail. Continue past Adessa (car auction), Fed Ex. Turn right at the first street (Conewago Creek Rd); Continue for approximately .9 mile. Church will be on your right.
 
From the South: Take 83 North to the Strinestown exit (exit 28); Make a right at the end of exit ramp onto Susquehanna Trail. Continue past Adessa (car auction), Fed Ex. Turn right at the first street (Conewago Creek Rd); Continue for approximately .9 mile. Church will be on your right.